Conscientious Objection in Health Care: An Ethical Analysis

Historically associated with military service, conscientious objection has become a significant phenomenon in health care. Mark Wicclair offers a comprehensive ethical analysis of conscientious objection in three representative health care professions:: medicine, nursing and pharmacy. He critically examines two extreme positions:: the incompatibility thesis, that it is contrary to the professional obligations of practitioners to refuse provision of any service within the scope of their professional competence; and conscience absolutism, that they should be exempted from performing any action contrary to their conscience. He argues for a compromise approach that accommodates conscience-based refusals within the limits of specified ethical constraints. He also explores conscientious objection by students in each of the three professions, discusses conscience protection legislation and conscience-based refusals by pharmacies and hospitals, and analyzes several cases. His book is a valuable resource for scholars, professionals, trainees, students, and anyone interested in this increasingly important aspect of health care.